Skip to main content
toothlocal

How we know

Every statement on toothlocal comes from a public source we can point to. Here is what we use, how each number on a practice page is worked out, and what we leave out.

Sources

  • Public business listings and 24.7 million patient reviews, up to 20 September 2026.
  • The practices' own websites, checked Sep 2026: services, published prices, insurers named, technology, and dentists' biographies (dental school, training, languages).
  • Texas State Board of Dental Examiners: license status, first license date, dental school, sedation permits and nitrous oxide permits.
  • Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation: license status and first license date.
  • The NPI registry (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services): which dentists work at which practice, and listed specialties.
  • Insure Kids Now (US Department of Health and Human Services): Medicaid and CHIP dental plans for children (updated Jul 2026).
  • City of Chicago, City of Houston and City of Austin open data: official neighborhood boundaries.

Which reviews we count

The written reviews on each practice's public business listing, up to 20 September 2026. Star-only reviews count in the rating but not in themes.

Ratings are shown as floors, such as “4.5+ stars in 500+ reviews”, rather than exact scores that change daily. “93% give 4–5 stars” is the share of its written reviews.

What patients say (themes and counts)

We look for themes, such as “gentle hands” or “explains everything”, across every written review. Each theme is checked by reading samples of the matching reviews; a theme is used only if at least 9 in 10 of the reviews we read are really about it.

“23 reviews describe a beautiful, modern office” means 23 of that practice's written reviews match the theme. We describe each theme in our own words and never copy reviews onto the page. Themes about chains in general, dated subjects (such as COVID-era rules) and anything about taking new patients are never used.

Reports

The same reading of patient reviews, counted across the whole country, goes into our data reports. The first, the AI Review Index, measures how much of what patients write, and what practices write back, now shows signs of AI.

How it compares in the city

Each figure in “How it compares” is the practice's own, set beside the same figure for the other practices in its city. “Middle Chicago practice: 5%” is the median: half the city's practices are above it and half below. Review figures use the practices with at least 20 written reviews; license years use every dentist we have confirmed at a practice in that city.

“Licensed in Illinois since 2009” is the earliest first-license date among the practice's confirmed dentists in that state's board records. A dentist may have practiced in another state before.

What unhappy patients say

For this section we read every one- and two-star written review of the practice from the last three years in full. Each review is read with AI against a fixed list of reasons (such as long waits, billing higher than quoted, insurance problems or pressure to have treatment), so counts mean the same thing on every page. One review can give several reasons.

Reviews that are really about another practice or an insurer, or that have no complaint, are not counted. We count how many reviews give each reason and describe them in our own words; reviews are never copied onto the page. The reasons are the patients', not our judgement of the practice.

Recent reviews and replies

“In the last 12 months” means the year up to 20 September 2026. We compare the share of 4–5 star reviews in that year with the share before it, and only when the year has at least 10 written reviews; “up from” or “down from” appears when the difference is 5 points or more and there are at least 20 earlier reviews.

“The practice replies to 8% of written reviews” counts the written reviews that carry a reply from the business, shown when a practice has at least 20.

Prices and price comparisons

Prices are the starting prices a practice publishes on its own website (Sep 2026), linked to the page they came from. A “from” price is the lowest it advertises; your treatment may cost more. An emergency exam or new-patient special is the price itself.

“Lower than 7 of the 11 other Austin practices that publish one” compares that price with the other independent practices in the same city that publish a price for the same treatment on their own websites. Chains are left out, and a comparison is shown only when at least 5 other practices publish one. Prices change: always confirm when you call.

Opening hours

Hours come from the practice's business listing. “Open on Saturdays, which only 12% of Austin practices with listed hours are” compares it with the practices in the same city that list their hours.

Listed hours that look wrong for a dental office (closing after 9 pm, or open more than 13 hours in a day) are shown with a note to check them, and are never used to recommend a practice.

Dentists, licenses and permits

A dentist is shown only when their full name appears on the practice's own website or business listing and matches an NPI record at that practice. License facts come from the state board for that NPI.

Dental school comes from the Texas board's records in Texas. Elsewhere, and for training and languages everywhere, it comes from the dentist's biography on the practice's own website, marked “(its website)”: we keep a fact only when the biography states it about that dentist by name, and never guess a language from a name.

In Texas, a sedation permit (levels 1 to 4) and a nitrous oxide permit are different permits, and we name them separately. A practice is called a specialist only when the state board lists the specialty; a specialty listed in the NPI registry is self-reported and said to be so.

Neighborhoods

A practice's neighborhood comes from where its map pin falls in the city's own official areas: Chicago's 77 community areas and Houston's 88 super neighborhoods. In Austin we use the city's neighborhood planning areas in the center and the neighborhood named on the practice's business listing elsewhere, because the planning areas do not cover the whole city.

Practices outside those areas (for example, Houston addresses outside the city limits) and areas with fewer than three practices are grouped by ZIP code instead.

How we count practices

A practice is one open office. We merge listings that share a phone and address, and leave out locations with no sign of activity in two years. The method and the checks are in the practices report.

Phone numbers

The number shown is the one on the practice's business listing. Some listings use a call-tracking number. When the listing's number is not on the practice's website and the website gives a different number beside its own address, we show that one too, as “Its website gives …”.

Medicaid and CHIP

Plans come from Insure Kids Now and are shown only when its provider record shares the practice's phone number and ZIP code. They cover children's dental care. We never say a practice is in network with a private insurer: insurers named on a practice's website are listed as named, not checked.

The questions on each page

Questions come from what people search for about dentists (cost, pain and nerves, getting seen quickly, waiting, kids, language, hours). A practice gets a question only when its own evidence answers it, so pages ask different questions. No question asks whether a practice takes an insurance plan.

How we write the review summaries and answers

The summary under “Is it a good dentist?” and the answers to questions sum up that practice's own evidence, as described above. They are written with AI from those facts and nothing else. The data decides what a summary says first: a recent change in ratings, a price, unusual hours or what patients describe most.

Before anything is published, software checks that every number, price and hour matches our records, that words of amount (“often”, “many”) are not used where the numbers are small, and that nothing claims what we cannot know. A second AI read then checks every claim against the facts. A summary that fails is rewritten once; if it fails again, it is not published.

Then a person on our team reads every summary beside the facts it came from and approves or rejects it. Nothing is published automatically, and a summary goes back for review whenever its facts change. Opinions are the patients', never ours.

What we do not show

  • Whether a practice is accepting new patients: listings are often out of date. Call to ask.
  • Names we cannot confirm: a dentist linked only by address or phone is not shown.
  • Insurance networks: insurers named on a practice's website are listed as such, not as a network check.
  • Our own opinion of a dentist's skill or care: we report what patients say and what records show.

Updates and mistakes

We refresh listings, reviews, websites and public records every quarter, and each page shows its dates. If something is wrong, use the corrections form: we check it against the source and fix the page. Every fix and change is listed, with its date and source, on corrections and changes.